Training your dog can often seem like a real challenge.
One of the most frustrating habits to correct is excessive and inappropriate barking, so what can you do to fight back?
Well, the obvious solution is to invest in a training collar, but this can be incredibly confusing if you don’t know what you’re looking for.
Luckily, we’re here today to guide you every step of the way. Since there are so many different collars up for grabs, we’ll first outline various training methods. By the time you reach our reviews, you should be well-placed to decide which type of training would work best for your dog.
To get things started, you need to think about the different types of training collar so you can determine which would most suit your pooch.
These are the main types of no-bark training collars:
Browse our showcase of the best dog training collars to see which of these, if any, make the right fit for you.
Rabieschallengefund.org is reader-supported. When you buy via the links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.
The 12 Best Dog Training Collars
1. Our Pick Sport DOG 425X Remote Trainer
Sport DOG is one of the most reputable brands in the dog training vertical, so how does this remote trainer stand and fall?
You must first choose between a collar for one or two dogs, depending on your setup. This model is intended for a single dog. You can also choose between this e-collar, a variant designed for stubborn dogs, or a camo collar.
Ideal for outdoor training in large open spaces, the collar has an impressive range of 1500 feet (500 yards).
Multiple training modes let you use static shock, vibration, or only an audible tone. This lets you use the most appropriate correction method for the breed and temperament of your dog. You can work your way through 21 different levels of static correction, delivering incrementally stronger shocks if your pooch doesn’t respond to correction.
The lithium-ion batteries can be rapidly charged in just two hours. You can expect anywhere from 50 to 70 hours of run time, according to the manufacturer’s claims. The rechargeable nature of the batteries means you’ll cut down running costs.
Rugged and built to last, this training collar is waterproof and submersible to depths of 25 feet thanks to the DryTek tech baked in.
You get everything you need bundled to get going right out the box, but does this training collar make the right fit for your pup?
2. Educator E-Collar
As outlined above, not all dog owners are comfortable using static shock training collars on their furballs. Educator offers the optimum solution in the form of this humane training device that inhibits excessive barking through a tapping sensation.
This iteration is finished in bright yellow. There are four alternative colorways if this doesn’t appeal.
A single-dog system with a range of ½ mile, you can head out into wide open spaces without worrying about losing control of Fido.
The tapping sensation this collar delivers to your dog if he barks too much is similar to the vibration using on many training collars. This is totally humane and does not involve static shock.
There are 100 standard settings, allowing you to use progressively more correction if your dog doesn’t fall in line. You can also activate a boost feature with 60 extra notches.
If you plan to use this collar on your dog for more than 8 hours a day, you can opt for the titanium contact points. There are also contact points designed with short-haired dogs in mind, so choose accordingly.
Note that this training collar is only intended for use in the United States, so bear this in mind if you live elsewhere and explore some of the many alternatives highlighted above and below.
Backed by a two-year guarantee, you can expect plenty of faithful service from this training collar without breaking the bank or hurting your beloved pooch.
3. DOG CARE Dog Training Collar
Next in line is a highly versatile collar from industry specialist DOG CARE suitable for all dogs of all shapes, sizes, and breeds.
Like many of the best dog training collars, this model comes equipped with three separate training modes. Dogs who are resistant to milder methods of correction may benefit from the 99 graded static shocks. Owners who dislike the idea of using static shock correction can choose from a vibration alert or an audible beep, both capable of discouraging dogs from barking excessively.
When you’re training your dog outdoors using this collar, you can do so over a range of 1000 feet. This gives you more range than offered by much of the opposition.
You can deliver a full burst of charge in just two hours with lengthy run times from the rechargeable lithium-ion batteries.
Overall build quality is solid and long-lasting despite the fairly cheap looks. Rated both waterproof and dustproof, this collar can withstand plenty of rough and tumble.
Although the collar is a solid contender, many disgruntled consumers compare this uprated version unfavorably to the outgoing model. If you can find one of the older generation collars, it’s well worth exploring that as an option.
This is a flexible and very effective collar for many different types of dogs, but is the right one for you?
4. PetSafe Remote Training Collar
PetSafe is one of the best-known brands in this crowded market segment, so how does this training collar stand up?
The collar is intended for training small and medium dogs off the leash in areas up to 900 feet.
You first need to choose from many options, including:
- Number of dogs
- Size of dogs
This version is suitable for one medium or large dog and has a 300-yard (900-foot) range.
Like most of the more popular training collars up for grabs, this model allows you to choose between multiple methods of correction. Not all dogs respond to all types of correction, and not all dog owners are comfortable with static shock collars. The PetSafe gives you the freedom to use the method of correction that best suits in one handy device.
The quick-charging batteries will be ready for action after just two hours, and capable of lasting for up to 40 hours.
Lightweight and waterproof, the collar won’t weigh your dog down and will cope well if there is a rain shower or if your dog goes into the water when you’re out for walkies.
If you run into any problems at all, this manufacturer has a responsive and helpful customer care department, so you’re in safe hands with PetSafe.
5. Dogtra Remote Training Collar
As we near the midway point of our dog training collar reviews, an offering from another industry heavyweight, Dogtra. What do you get for your money here, then?
Perhaps the key selling point of this collar is the enormous range. The collar works within a range of ¾ mile, making it one of the strongest performers in the field.
The durable collar is specifically designed with the needs of large dogs in mind. If your furball weighs 35 pounds or more and barks excessively, this could be the ideal solution.
The vibration collar should be a good fit for dogs of all temperaments, including stubborn dogs who are resistant to positive reinforcement. The collar is not suitable for aggressive dogs.
As with all training collars, you should supplement the reinforcement with plenty of treats and affection when your pup complies with correction.
The US-based customer care allows you to access help quickly and easily if you run into any problems when training your dog with this collar.
The only significant drawback is the fairly high cost of this collar, but for those with more flexible budgets, it’s one of the best options out there, and it’s also completely humane.
6. Garmin Alpha 100 Bundle
GPS specialist Garmin serves up the Alpha 100 for those who want to closely monitor the movements of their dog in the field.
You can track as many as 9 dogs using this device over a sprawling range of 9 miles. The smaller device has a 4-mile range.
Keep an eye on the speed of your dog’s movements and chart the distance he travels.
For training purposes, you can take advantage of 18 different levels of momentary or continuous stimulation. This should prevent your dog from barking too much. Alerts are either a vibration or an audible tone. This training collar does not use static shock correction, making it a humane training solution ideal for many breeds and temperaments.
If you want to ensure that your pup stays out of danger, you can create virtual fences using the Garmin, receiving alerts if your dog breaches the boundaries.
Note that this training collar is only suitable for use in the United States and comes pre-loaded with maps. The collar is not intended for use in Canada. Choose the Astro 300 with worldwide mapping if you live outside the U.S.
7. Bousnic Dog Training Collar
Do you have a small or medium dog? If so, the Bousnic training collar allows you to prevent him from barking too much when you’re out and about.
The versatile collar is equipped with multiple correction methods, allowing you to pick from static shocks, vibration, or audible tones. Depending on the temperament of your dog and how receptive he is to training, one of these methods should stop him from excessive barking.
The lightweight collar is finished in a hardwearing nylon. Ideal for outdoor use in almost any conditions, the Bousnic is rated IP67 waterproof.
The long-lasting batteries are capable of returning up to two weeks of use, meaning you won’t find yourself constantly scuttling to the charger.
The dual-channel remote allows you to train more than one dog using the same remote. You’ll need to pick up an additional collar from the manufacturer at extra cost, but this still saves you money over buying another training collar and remote.
There is no charging adapter bundled. You’ll need to use any USB cable and outlet for worldwide convenience.
Although this collar has no bells or whistles, it’s a highly effective training device from a trusted brand, so what are you waiting for?
8. UKE Dog Training Collar
Next in line is another flexible solution to training your dog outdoors.
Intended for use with dogs of all shapes, sizes, and breeds, the UKE is another unit with three different methods of correction. Whether your dog responds most favorably to static shocks, audible tones, or vibration, you have all of these onboard the UKE.
If you decide that static shock correction is the most expedient way of stopping your furball from barking too much, you can use progressive correction through 99 different levels.
The collar itself is superlight and won’t burden your dog unnecessarily. Made of a rugged and waterproof nylon, you’ll get plenty of use from this thing.
You should find the remote is easily manageable and user-friendly. It comes with a lock feature to prevent any unwanted correction if you place the remote in your pocket.
The manufacturer does not stipulate how long the batteries last, other than to say they are long-life.
Arguably the main benefit of this training collar is the 2600-foot range, giving you freedom when roaming in large open spaces with your dog.
9. Dogtra 280C Remote Training Collar
Another entry from the ever-reliable Dogtra stable as we near the end of today’s showcase of the best dog training collars.
This collar is suitable for dogs weighing 10 pounds and upwards with neck sizes from 6 inches to 24 inches. Designed for all breeds with mild and moderate temperaments, you have plenty of latitude with this innovative training solution.
The collar offers three different training modes:
- Non-stimulating vibration
- Constant stimulation
- Momentary nick
You can impart a full charge to the lithium-ion batteries in just two hours, minimizing downtime and offering you rechargeable convenience and low running costs.
The collar, receiver, and transmitter are all waterproof, giving you the freedom to roam with Fido in all winds and weathers, and down by the water.
The customer care department is based in the United States and provides a seamless service if you run into any interference when using the training device on your furball.
10. PetSpy Dog Training Collar
As we come to the end of our dog training collar reviews, we have time for a few more devices, including the PetSpy.
Whether you’re a veteran dog owner or a first-time pet parent, you may need to bring your dog into line if he barks excessively or inappropriately.
Choose from three training modes to suit the temperament and obedience levels of your pup. Some dogs respond better to vibration or audible tones than static shocks, and many owners prefer not to use static shock correction. This flexible and highly effective collar covers all bases in a single compact device.
The collar comes equipped with a buckle closure, making it super-simple to put on and remove.
You also get plenty of leeway when it comes to the size and breed of your pooch. This collar will fit dogs weighing 10 to 140 pounds.
Range is exceptional with up to 650 yards of coverage. That translates to just under 2000 feet, making this one of the most capable training collars in terms of range.
As with many of the collars we review today, this brand backs up a first-class product with excellent customer service, allowing you to buy with complete confidence for much less than you might imagine.
11. DOG CARE Training Collar
We have time for another offering from DOG CARE in the form of this outstanding collar. Not only is this one of the best training collars out there, but it’s also one of the cheapest. If you’re hunting for bargain without compromising quality, read on.
Equipped with multiple training modes, you can experiment and discover which method of correction most efficiently stops your dog from barking uncontrollably.
The remote control has a lock so you won’t get any accidental misfires when you slip the control into your pocket.
Use a single transmitter to control up to nine dogs, assuming you purchase additional collars.
Rated IPX65 waterproof, your dog can jump in the sea or the lake without you needing to worry about the collar malfunctioning.
Wireless control extends to 330 yards, which is almost 1000 feet.
Designed to fit canines from 15 to 100 pounds, place your trust in DOG CARE and enjoy a walk with your dog uninterrupted by constant barking.
12. Flittor Dog Training Collar
Flittor might not be the first name that springs to mind when you think of dog training collars, but this model is well worth a place on your shortlist.
Suitable for small, medium, or large dogs, you’ll benefit from wireless correction at a range of up to 1000 feet.
Packing three separate modes of correction, choose from static correction, audible tones, or vibration depending on the temperament of your dog, his obedience levels, and how receptive he is to positive reinforcement.
The dual-channel design allows you to accommodate more than one dog by purchasing additional collars and using the same remote.
With a security lock onboard, your dog will be protected from any unwanted correction.
Whether your dog tends to bark excessively, pee inappropriately, or exhibits any other type of aggressive behavior, this collar combined with treats and affection could be make a significant difference.
As with all the collars we review today, you may find that this model fails to stop your dog from barking too much. If this occurs, consider engaging the services of a professional dog trainer.
1) What are no-bark collars?
No-bark collars are known by many different names. You might also see them referred to as dog training collars, shock collars, or anti-bark collars. These collars come in many different types. Correction is administered by ultrasonic beeps, static shocks, pulsing vibrations, or sprays of citronella. Whatever the style of correction, all training collars have the same goal: to prevent dogs from barking too much.
2) What is positive reinforcement?
When you’re training your dog to stop barking excessively, to sit, or to obey your commands, using punishment as the sole training technique is both cruel and ineffective. Incorporate reward if your dog complies with your commands and that’s positive reinforcement for you. This is the kindest and also by far the most efficient training technique overall. It is impossible to give a dog too much affection or too many treats. Always reward good behavior when training your furball.
3) Are static shock collars safe to use on my dog?
Yes. Using this type of collar will deliver a short, sharp shock of similar intensity like the static shocks you get when touching metal after walking on carpeted surfaces. While this will not trigger severe or lasting pain, many dog owners feel that these collars are inhumane. If you are comfortable with this low-level shock when you’re training your pooch, there are many great collars that are safe to use.
4) Does a spray collar work?
Yes. Most spray collars use citronella spray. Dogs hate the smell of citrus, and your canine won’t enjoy a snout smelling of lemon. Alternatively, use unscented spray as dogs don’t like their fur or snouts getting wet. When your dog is barking excessively, use a few bursts of citronella spray and he will soon mend his ways.
5) What are always-on training collars?
Unlike remote control training collars, you leave these collars in place. The integrated sensors ensure that your pooch receives correction for excessive barking, even if you’re not around. Safety features like auto shut-off remove the possibility of over-correction. This type of collar is perfect if your dog is susceptible to barking and spends long spells unattended. You should not use this type of collar for more than 12 hours in one stretch.
6) I have more than one dog. Can I train all 4 of my dogs with one collar?
You’ll need to buy separate collars but many of the units we look at today allow you to use a single remote receiver along with additional collars. You’ll save money this way and you’ll also only need one remote control.
7) What should I do if my dog’s neck looks irritated after using the collar?
Occasionally, you might find your dog is sensitive to the prongs on these training collars. Make sure you always keep the prongs clean and disinfected. Check the skin around the collar and keep an eye on your dog itching and scratching. If you find your dog is intolerant to the collar, you should immediately discontinue use.
8) Is it acceptable to use a training collar on a puppy?
It’s not, no. You should wait until your dog is at least 6 months old before embarking on a training program that calls for a no-bark collar.
9) Do ultrasonic devices really work?
This type of correction device can work, yes. Usually handheld and effective only over short range, the high-pitched sounds might not register on your radar, but your dog will find the noise unpleasant enough that she should modify her behavior.
10) What’s the best no-bark collar?
There isn’t a single collar we could term the best. All that counts is finding what works for your dog. If you’re uncertain where to start, we would strongly recommend investing in a multipurpose collar that gives you a choice of correction methods. You can then assess which works best.
Well, by now you should be completely clear on how the various types of dog training collar. You should also have an accurate idea of which variety would make the most effective training device for your canine.
This is one purchase you should not rush into headlong. Consider the temperament of your dog and whether or not they have responded to other forms of correction. Time spent before purchase can easily save you from wasting your money.
When you have the training collar in place, pay attention to the tips we outlined above, and you should find your dog stops barking too much in a short time.
Come back soon! We’re just starting out, but we have an aggressive content calendar in place, and we aim to become your first-line resource for all things dog-related.