Dog training collars are devices used to train dogs not to perform negative behaviors like excessively barking.

Canine training collars are designed to help pets to discover how they should behave in certain situations, and they can also be used as a corrective measure.

There are many different types of training collar on the market, and many people find that these collars are a central component of training their dogs.

What can you do, though, if you want a humane alternative to the many dog training collars that deliver static shock correction?

Well, you can find many different types of no-shock dog collar. The most popular of these use the following methods of correction to discourage your dog from barking:

  • Vibration
  • Audible tone or beepS
  • pray

Many no-shock collars come with remote controls and fairly impressive ranges, allowing you to train your dog in wide open spaces, as well as when you’re working with him in the yard. As an aside, it is also worth considering a cheap fence to supplement other training methods.

Luckily, it is straightforward to choose a humane dog training collar as long as you know what you’re looking for. Consider the following pointers before committing to purchase:

  • Size and weight of dogs: One of the first and most crucial elements to determine is the sizing of the dog collar relative to your pooch. To make things easier for you, we have categorized the size of each of the collars we review, by the size or the weights of the dogs they are intended for. If you end up with a collar that’s too large for your furball, it is liable to chafe or to slip off completely. Pick a collar that’s too small and lightweight for the canine breed in question, and he may find it challenging to bear the pressure of the collar. This could easily lead to skin irritation or sores. It is also well worth checking that any collars on your shortlist are suitably sized for the circumference of your dog’s neck.
  • Materials: Leather training collars are initially more expensive, but they tend to last for longer than metal or plastic collars. Beyond this, look for high-quality materials if you want a collar with a lengthy lifespan.
  • Functionality: Ensure that all the no-shock dog collars on your shortlist offer you a user-friendly experience in line with your needs. Establish that you are getting the right method of correction for your dog, and make sure the collar is easy to put on and remove.
  • Safety: Always make certain that your dog is comfortable when fitted with a new collar. Monitor them closely during the initial stages and make sure that the collar causes no pain, no discomfort, and no skin irritation.
  • Intended use: Think closely about the environment in which you will be using the collar. If you will frequently be using the training device near water, look for a collar equipped with a quick-release clasp. Think, too, about how often you will be using the training collar. Ask yourself whether your pooch has any existing behavioral problems. If so, you might find that a no-shock collar alone fails to deliver sufficient correction.

As long as you take your time to determine the needs of you and your furball, you should find one tailored to your needs from today’s showcase of the best no-shock dog training collars out there.

Read on! is reader-supported. When you buy via the links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.

The 9 Best No Shock Dog Training Collars

1. Our Pick Good Boy Mini No-Shock Remote Collar



  • Type of dog: Small and medium
  • Method of correction: Beep and vibration
  • Dimensions: 2 x 1.3 x 0.7 inches

Our favorite collar from today’s collection of completely humane training devices comes from Good Boy in the guise of the Mini No-Shock Collar with remote.

If you have a smaller dog at home, this is one of the best training collars that doesn’t rely on static correction. Dogs weighing as little as 5 pounds can comfortably wear this superlight collar without being burdened.

On the flipside, the size of the device and the absence of static correction means that stubborn dogs and dogs weighing over 15 pounds may not respond positively to this training collar.

Bundled with a remote control and boasting a range of 1000 feet, this collar is tailor-made for training small dogs not to bark excessively in public. You could also, of course, utilize the training collar out in the back yard.

There is an audible tone that might be enough to stop some obedient dogs from misbehaving. If you need to rely on vibration to correct a more willful small dog, you can increase the intensity of the vibration through 7 different levels until you deliver enough discouragement for your dog to comply with your command.

The sleek remote is made from plastic and has a matte finish. This remote feels hardwearing, and it is also rated waterproof.

You could also use this collar to train your dog in the following areas beyond excessive barking:

  • Digging under a fence
  • Soiling
  • Not coming if called
  • Aggression
  • Disobedience
  • Running off
  • Jumping

As an added bonus, you’ll get a comprehensive training guide included with this collar, ideal for inexperienced or first-time dog owners.

Things We Like

  • Perfect snug fit for smaller breeds
  • Impressive 1000-foot range
  • Lengthy runtime

Things We Dislike

  • Remote enters sleep mode too quickly

2. Paws Furlosophy No-Shock Training Collar



  • Type of dog: Most breeds weighing from 22 to 100 pounds
  • Method of correction: Light, tone, and vibration
  • Dimensions: 6.3 x 4.7 x 2.4 inches

Next up is another humane training collar for dogs, this time from Paws Furlosophy. What do you get for your money, then?

Firstly, this is one of the most cost effective options up for grabs if you need to discourage your dog from barking too much and you are not prepared to resort to shock collars that use static correction.

This model gives you three different modes of correction. Smaller and more obedient breeds may respond to the light or tone that warns them against excessive barking and other negative or destructive behaviors. You may find, though, that you need to introduce vibrating correction to achieve a response from your furball. If so, this collar is equipped with 16 levels of vibration.

There is a hardwearing remote that’s backlit with LED lights and allows you to train your dog at distances of up to 1,950 feet.

The receiver is rated IPX7 waterproof, meaning you can allow your dog into the water without any worries.

One of the only meaningful drawbacks with this collar is the underwhelming battery life. Think closely about your intended usage and determine whether or not this is a deal-breaker.

Considering the almost budget pricing, this is one of the most effective no-shock training collars out there, but does it make the right choice for your pooch?

Things We Like

  • 3 different modes of correction
  • 16 different vibration levels
  • IPX7 waterproofed

Things We Dislike

  • Battery performance is weak

3. Paipatek No-Shock Training Collar



  • Type of dog: Small and medium
  • Method of correction: Beep and vibration
  • Dimensions: 2.3 x 1.4 x 1.1 inches

Paipatek serves up one of the cheapest no-shock dog training collars that doesn’t force your to compromise on effectiveness. That said, the build quality of this collar and receiver reflects the budget pricing. Lifespan may be affected correspondingly.

One of the primary benefits of this no-shock collar is the sprawling range of 1,600 feet. Whether you’re looking to train your pup in the yard or out in public, you can do so at a distance.

This collar offers two different methods of correction. An audible tone might be enough to stop some dogs short when they are misbehaving. Alternatively, take advantage of the ten different levels of vibrating alert on the collar. Ratchet these up incrementally to deliver only the amount of correction needed with no concerns about hurting your furry friend.

Ideal for small and medium breeds, the collar is also beneficial for training puppies or deaf dogs.

The other key selling point here is the impressively lengthy runtime. While this is obviously contingent on the amount you use the collar, you could get up to 20 days of runtime from the batteries before they need a burst of charge.

If you’re looking to invest in a cheap but efficient training collar that’s also totally humane, what are you waiting for?

Things We Like

  • Class-leading 1600-foot range
  • Weeks of runtime
  • Completely waterproof collar

Things We Dislike

  • Build quality issues may develop prematurely

4. WOLFWILL Humane Dog Training Collar



  • Type of dog: Most breeds weighing from 22 to 88 pounds
  • Method of correction: Light, tone, and vibration
  • Dimensions: 2.5 x 5.2 x 2.5 inches

WOLFWILL is one of the strongest brands in a crowded market segment, providing highly effective training collars that correct your dog without resorting to static shock correction.

This model offers three humane alternatives to static shock correction. The light and tone may prove effective if your dog is compliant and receptive to training. If you have a more stubborn pooch, try using the vibrating alert to discourage him from behaving poorly. There are 16 adjustable levels, allowing you to increase correction gradually until you achieve the desired result.

Despite the reasonable price point, you’ll benefit from some generous extras, including:

  • Belt clip
  • Neck strap
  • Splitter charging cable

Bundled with lithium-ion batteries, you can deliver a quick burst of charge in just two hours, making this one of the most convenient no-shock training collars you’ll find. Although the auto shut-off feature prolongs battery life, this tends to kick in too quickly.

The remote control bundled can help you to control two dogs, as long as you invest in an extra collar. This saves you from buying two complete systems if you have more than one dog at home.

Rated waterproof and boasting a 1,950-foot range, this flexible and affordable no-shock training collar is humane and likely to give you years of faithful service. Let us know how you get on in the comments below if you invest in this humane canine collar for Fido.

Things We Like

  • Neck strap and belt clip bundled
  • Straightforward blind use
  • Rugged and waterproof

Things We Dislike

  • Prone to suddenly powering down

Vibration Bark Collars

5. DogRook Bark Collar



  • Type of dog: Most breeds weighing from 8 to 110 pounds
  • Method of correction: Beep and vibration
  • Dimensions: 1.6 x 1 x 2.8 inches

DogRook is a budget brand that produces attractive and hardwearing dog equipment for much less than most of the opposition. Is it any good, though?

In a word, yes! The first benefit of this model is the broad compatibility. Many collars are only intended for certain breeds, and they come with reasonably tight weight and neck size restrictions. The DogRook, by contrast, is suitable for almost all dogs, from small through to larger breeds.

You will get a choice of four striking colorways to suit the temperament of your pup, including this pastel blue offering.

The waterproof nature of this equipment makes it a safe bet if you frequently take your dog for walkies in rainy conditions or near the water.

Rechargeable batteries slash running costs. You can expect up to two weeks of use from the collar, depending on how often you need to deliver correction.

One significant advantage here is the smart nature of the collar. This only recognizes the bark of your dog, something that will minimize any false triggers during training.

Things We Like

  • Flexible collar ideal for most dogs
  • Multiple levels of audio and vibration to correct barking
  • Waterproof and rechargeable

Things We Dislike

  • Quality control concerns

6. PetSafe Spray Bark Collar



  • Type of dog: Most breeds weighing from 8 pounds upwards
  • Method of correction: Citronella spray
  • Dimensions: 6.2 x 6.4 x 2.8 inches

PetSafe is perhaps the most widely known and also the most reputable brand retailing dog equipment. How does this no-shock collar stand and fall, then?

As you would expect from PetSafe, overall build quality is rock solid, and this collar should return plenty of service.

The plastic and canvas build is finished in a muted blue colorway, and the lightweight collar makes a good fit for most dogs weighing upwards of 8 pounds.

Unlike most of the competing no-shock collars, this model does not use audible alerts, and it does not use vibrating alerts either. Instead, the collar administers metered doses of a citronella spray when your dog behaves poorly or barks too much. Not only do dogs dislike getting their noses wet, but they also loathe the smell of citronella, making this approach to training doubly effective.

Invest in a humane training collar made by a brand with a quarter-century of experience and pay far less than you might imagine. Just remember to factor in the ongoing expense of the citronella spray refills and you’re good to go.

Charge the batteries for just 2 hours to enjoy up to 40 hours of runtime.

The intelligent nature of this collar tunes out all barks other than that of your dog, eliminating false positive and making training a seamless affair.

Things We Like

  • Highly reputable brand
  • Humane but effective
  • Friendly and responsive customer care

Things We Dislike

  • Unit is highly sensitive

7. Paw Pets Dog Bark Collar



  • Type of dog: Most dogs weighing from 5 to 110 pounds
  • Method of correction: Beep and vibration
  • Dimensions: 3.1 x 3.5 x 1.7 inches

As we near the end of our collection of the best no-shock dog training collars, we have another cost-effective model, this time from the Paw Pets stable.

The twin-pack comes in a bright blue and orange to introduce some fun into training Fido. The plastic and nylon build is dependable and long-lasting, despite the budget pricing of this collar.

Ideal for a broad cross-section of breeds, the collar will fit most dogs within the weight range of 5 to 110 pounds. If your furball falls outside these weights, you should look for a collar designed for teacup breeds or for larger breeds respectively.

The collar is equipped with a pair of humane training modes. Obedient dogs may respond to the audible tone discouraging them from barking too much. If you require more correction, this model uses a vibrating alert rather than static shock correction, ideal for guiding your dog without hurting him in any way.

While the collar itself is a solid example with no obvious flaws, the instructions are printed in a font so small you may need a magnifying class to read them.

Setting this aside, you’re buying an efficient and humane method of correcting excessive canine barking, and you’ll also benefit from a generous range of extras, including differently colored faceplates so you can ring the changes.

Things We Like

  • Works well for most dogs
  • Attractive set of extras included
  • Remote-free training tool

Things We Dislike

  • Very poor instructions

8. NPS No-Shock Bark Collar



  • Type of dog: Small and medium
  • Method of correction: Beep and vibration
  • Dimensions: 1.5 x 1.5 x 2.5 inches

If you have a small or medium breed at home, what can you do if your pooch barks too much?

This lightweight but substantial collar doesn’t use static shock to prevent excessive barking, but instead uses audible alerts or vibration to drive the message home humanely.

Suitable for dogs of all life stages and of most sizes, you may find that much larger breeds require a more robust collar.

There is an integrated smart chip that serves to tune out all barks except the bark of your dog. As such, you shouldn’t be menaced by too many annoying false positives when you’re training Rover with this collar.

The collar is highly adjustable, allowing you to achieve a snug fit with most breeds. Weight distribution is also highly effective, delivering a comfortable collar that won’t weigh your pooch down.

Things We Like

  • For most dogs of all life stages
  • Hands-free and humane bark control
  • Few false positives

Things We Dislike

  • Only good for short-term use

9. Pawious Bark Collar for Small Dogs



  • Type of dog: Small and medium
  • Method of correction: Beep and vibration
  • Dimensions: 3.6 x 1.8 x 3.2 inches

To round out today’s reviews, we have a no-shock collar from Pawious that enables you to train your dog not to bark too much without needing to deliver static shock correction.

Not only is this collar highly effective, but it’s also among the cheaper options.

The adjustable nylon strap is designed to withstand plenty of rough and tumble.

Ideal for most small and medium breeds, the collar should fit all dogs weighing from 7 to 80 pounds.

There are several different faceplates included, allowing you to add some color to training.

With no neck prongs and 7 different levels of audible and vibrating alert, stop your pup from barking when he shouldn’t without feeling guilty about the use of static shock correction.

Things We Like

  • Multiple colored faceplates
  • 7 progressive correction levels
  • Robust and long-lasting

Things We Dislike

  • Not recommended for larger breeds


1) Is it possible to train my dog without using a shock training collar?

This will depend entirely on the dog and how training has proceeded to date. Many dogs will respond to various alternative methods of correction, including:

  • Audible alerts
  • Vibrating alerts
  • Sprays (usually citronella sprays)

Until you try training your dog not to bark excessively, you won’t know which training methods will prove effective. Some pet parents try to overcome this by investing in collars that offer multiple methods of correction. Explore many of these models above.

2) Do non-shock training collars really work?

Yes. If you train your dog using plenty of positive reinforcement and humane methods like those outlined above, there is a good chance the no-shock collar will prove an effective training tool. A static shock collar delivers a shock, and the dog will respond immediately. When dogs are trained naturally, though, the focus is on praise and positive reinforcement rather than punitive measures.

3) How does a no-shock dog training collar work?

No-shock collars are easy to use. You will get a collar along with a receiver and, typically, a remote control. If you push a button on the remote, this sends a signal to the receiver and triggers a humane method of correction – usually an audible beep or a vibrating alert, although some collars utilize citronella sprays. Most electronic receivers come with metal probes that contact your dog’s skin and deliver correction as required.

4) Is if safe to use a training collar on my dog?

Yes, dog training collars are considered safe when used in line with the manufacturer’s instructions. Always start by using the lowest possible level of stimulation. If this doesn’t get the message home, you can gradually increase the intensity of correction. You should not leave training collars on your dog for more than 12 hours. Beyond this, you’ll also need to check regularly to make sure that the collar is not triggering any irritation to your dog.

5) Is it possible to use a no-shock training collar on my puppy?

Although most dogs receive the majority of their training while still puppies, most training collars are unsuitable for use on puppies younger than six months old. If you are attempting to train a younger puppy, you can use toys, treats, and clickers to reinforce your training commands. After this point, it is safe to introduce a no-shock training collar.


If you arrived here today at GO Boxer Rescue with no idea about how to train your dog not to bark excessively without resorting to static shock collars, this guide should have cleared up any confusion.

Regardless of the method of correction used, there is no guarantee that any collar will stop your dog from barking too much. For this reason, many first-time pet parents opt for canine training collars that offer multiple methods of correction in one unit.

Take a moment to bookmark our blog before you head off and be sure to pop back soon. We have a busy content calendar for the forthcoming holiday season, and we’ll be refreshing our content daily. See you soon!

5/5 - (5 votes)

About the Author

Rabies Challenge Fund

Share your thoughts

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

Want More Great Content?

Check Out These Articles